Undisclosed distillery: Born on Islay, house malt (en)

Another excellent surprise, that bottle who cannot be named and that costs thirtyeuros. It received 84.06 points average with 90 as highest rating, and a 78 as the lowest note. Further evidence that affordable whisky can sometimes be very good.
Here are the notes extremes:

Alouis	Color: intense gold Nose: Peat, on the cold ashes, and then moving rapidly toward rounder notes of sherry, chocolate and a hint of rubber. Then the cereals are entering followed by spices. Palate: The palate combination peat / rubber is perfect, just enough of both. Cereals are present, the cold ashes, a little iodine and sherry notes greedy. Finish: Long on flavor in the mouth.
Arno	Nose: beautiful nose on dry peat and a hint of bitumen. A fine blend of animal notes, quarry, leather and smoke. Ash and pepper. A dash of lemon juice? Wise, discreet, relaxed. Very nice. Taste: smooth without any acidity, meaty and dry peat. Comes spices and pepper on the end with a little lemon juice until it becomes a bit "burned". Takes his time, but great development! Final: meaty, smoky, smoked trout. Superb finish on this topic. Conclusion: play on lands of the sample # 2, this register meaty and smoky, but more wisely, with discretion and sharpness. So, very elegant. I appreciate!

mapi

Color: gold Nose with a hint of smoke. Alcohol is now quickly joined by notes of citrus. The nose ends with a disagreeable impression on the freshly cut grass and artichoke. The palate is fresh on the cereal and fresh fruit. The finish is medium, and fresh fruit Comment. I am baffled by this whisky. I do not know what to think. I assigned the lowest score of all my WDTS more to mark my disappointment as to assign a specific number.

The whole collection of notes is available on the following page: http://www.whisky-distilleries.info/WhiskyWDTS/2011-05/Bottle4_EN.shtml